Guide
Recovering declined and NSF membership payments.
A failed payment is money the club is owed. This guide explains what you may retry and when, what you may charge, how to remind members, and what happens if a member still does not pay.
Checked against the sources listed below on 1 November 2026. This is a plain-language guide, not legal advice. The rules change, and they differ by province.
The short version
- A bank debit returned for insufficient funds or funds not cleared may be retried once, within 30 days, for the same amount, with no fees added.
- A card that the issuer will never approve must not be resubmitted. Other declines are limited to 20 attempts in 30 days under Visa’s rules.
- The federal $10 NSF cap limits what the member’s bank charges the member. It does not set your fee.
- Put any returned-payment fee in the membership agreement.
- Keep reminders factual, with no promotion in them.
- In Alberta and Ontario you generally have two years to claim, and an acknowledgment of the debt can restart the clock.
When a bank debit bounces
Payments Canada’s Rule H1 names membership fees in its definition of a personal pre-authorized debit (PAD), so these rules cover monthly dues. The bank must return a dishonoured PAD no later than the business day after it reaches the unit that can decide.
If the debit came back for non-sufficient funds or funds not cleared, you may present it again on a one-time basis. It must be for the same amount, within 30 calendar days of the original transaction date, and it must not contain interest, NSF charges or any other charges. An NSF return does not cancel the member’s agreement, so regular billing carries on.
That retry covers those two reasons only. Your bank’s return report shows which one you have. National Bank of Canada publishes these codes, and other banks’ reports may word them differently:
- 901 insufficient funds and 908 funds not cleared: the two that may be retried.
- 902 account not found, 905 account closed and 912 invalid account number: get new banking details from the member.
- 903 payment stopped or recalled: talk to the member first.
- 915 agreement non-existent, 916 non-compliant to agreement, 917 agreement revoked and 918 no confirmation or prior notice: check your paperwork, because these can turn into a dispute.
A member can dispute a personal PAD for 90 calendar days. Our guide to EFT and pre-authorized debit covers the agreement in full.
When a card declines
Visa’s rules, in the edition dated 24 October 2026, sort declines into groups, and the group decides what you may do.
- Issuer will never approve: pick up card, invalid account number, lost, stolen, closed account, and stop payment orders. You must never resubmit these.
- Cannot approve at this time: not sufficient funds, over limit, and system problems. Retrying later is allowed.
- Data quality: an expired card or a failed security code. Fix the data first.
- Retryable groups are limited to 20 attempts in 30 days, and each retry must not change the data from the original request.
Mastercard’s rulebook could not be opened, so this comes from processors: payment processors report limits of 10 declined attempts in 24 hours and 35 in a rolling 30 days, with Canada named. Both networks charge fees for going over, and the amounts differ by processor, so read your own statement.
Expired and replaced cards
Visa Account Updater gives merchants new card numbers, new expiry dates and closed-account notices, and Visa requires issuers in Canada to enrol, with some exceptions. Mastercard’s Automatic Billing Updater does the same job for stored and recurring cards. Whether you can use either depends on your processor, so ask them.
What you can charge
Since 12 March 2026, federal regulations (SOR/2025-96) cap the NSF fee at $10 for federally regulated banks, on personal accounts. Banks typically charged about $45 to $48 before that. Provincially regulated credit unions and business accounts are not covered, and the cap says nothing about a gym’s own fee.
We could not find a general federal or provincial limit on what a business may charge for a returned payment. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada names three limits: $25 for federal departments, $20 for payday lenders, and Quebec, which generally limits payees to the actual bank charges they pay. It says merchants typically charge $20 to $40 per declined transaction.
Ontario requires gym contracts to state the total cost, the number and amount of payments and any extra charges, so a returned-payment fee belongs in the agreement. Remember that it cannot go on the PAD retry. Ask your lawyer how to collect it.
Reminding the member
Under Canada’s anti-spam law, a message that solely gives factual information about an ongoing membership or account, or completes a transaction already agreed to, generally does not need consent. Keep a payment reminder to the facts: the amount, the date and how to pay. Do not add an offer. Include your business details and an unsubscribe, because those requirements still apply. Maximum penalties run to $10 million for a business.
Speed matters more than wording. The reminder should go out when the payment fails, and the member should be able to pay or update their details without calling the club.
If the member still does not pay
- Alberta: you have two years from when you knew or ought to have known about the claim, or 10 years after it arose, whichever comes first. An acknowledgment or part payment before expiry restarts the clock.
- Ontario: two years from discovery, with a 15-year ultimate limit. An acknowledgment of a set amount resets the date.
- In Alberta, collecting your own dues does not make you a collection agency, because the definition excludes the original creditor. If you hand the debt to an agency, use a licensed one.
- Alberta’s rules for agencies make good practice for a club too: no more than three unsolicited contacts in seven days, calls between 7 am and 10 pm, no discussing the debt with others, and no threats.
Make sure the agreement stands up
You can only collect what the contract supports, and in Ontario a supplier may not require or accept payment without a compliant agreement. Under Ontario’s Consumer Protection Act, 2002, a gym agreement must be written, signed and delivered with the prescribed contents. The term can be no longer than one year, there is a 10-day cooling-off period, and renewals need proper notice unless they are monthly with one month’s notice or less to end. The Consumer Protection Act, 2023 will replace this law once proclaimed, so check the current rules.
We found no gym-specific rules in Alberta’s Consumer Protection Act, but its general unfair-practice rules still apply. Rules differ by province, so have your agreement reviewed where you operate.
A routine that works
- Read the return code or decline reason before doing anything else.
- Retry a bank debit once only, if the reason allows it.
- Remind the member the same day, with the facts and a way to pay.
- Show the balance to staff at check-in, so it gets raised politely in person.
- Update expired card details through your processor’s updater service.
- Keep a record of each contact and any acknowledgment of the debt.
How InCharge handles it
InCharge Pay retries failed payments and reminds the member automatically. The outstanding balance shows on the member’s profile, at check-in and in the member app, where the member can pay it or update their card without calling the club. Billing carries on as normal once the balance is cleared. Save 15-25% in your payment processing costs. Let us do an analysis of your current payment processing costs and show you how much we can save you.
Sources
- Payments Canada, Rule H1: Pre-authorized Debits (PDF), checked 1 Nov 2026
- Payments Canada, Pre-authorized debit (business guide), checked 1 Nov 2026
- National Bank of Canada, Pre-authorized debit user guide, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Visa Core Rules, 24 Oct 2026 edition (PDF), checked 1 Nov 2026
- Visa Developer, Visa Account Updater, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Mastercard Developers, Automatic Billing Updater, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Checkout.com, Scheme fee adjustments, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Canada Gazette Part II, 26 Mar 2025, SOR/2025-96, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, New NSF fee regulations, 12 Mar 2026, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, Review of banking fees: non-sufficient funds, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Government of Ontario, Joining a gym or fitness club, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Ontario, Consumer Protection Act, 2002, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Ontario, O. Reg. 17/05, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Ontario, Consumer Protection Act, 2023, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Alberta, Limitations Act, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Ontario, Limitations Act, 2002, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Alberta, Collection agencies and debt repayment, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Alberta, AR 194/1999, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Ontario, Collection and Debt Settlement Services Act, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Canada’s anti-spam legislation, S.C. 2010, c. 23, checked 1 Nov 2026
- Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations, SOR/2013-221, checked 1 Nov 2026

See what InCharge can do for your club
Try the live demo: a real club, the member app and the reports, at your own pace. Or book a short demo and we will walk you through it with your own club in mind.
